Christmas Songs That Don’t Suck

There are plenty of people who enjoy listening to the same tired Christmas songs year after year. I’m not one of them. If you’ve ever spent a few holiday seasons working in retail, you know what I’m talking about. Clearing trashed fitting rooms and dealing with stressed-out customers are both temporarily worse than listening to a saccharine Christmas mix. But I can attest after you’ve heard Christina Aguilera belt out The Christmas Song four hundred times on store speakers, the song triggers a gag reflex ever after.  For this list of Christmas songs that don’t suck, I primarily looked for songs that specifically mention Christmas and aren’t entirely overplayed. I also appreciate songs that reflect the dark as well as the light side of the holidays, or tell a good story.

The entire playlist is above, except for #9, #13, and #16 which weren’t available on Youtube, so those song links are below and #9 is replaced with runner-up “Christmas Ghosts” in the playlist.

1. The Sonics - Santa Clause
Who doesn’t want a cute honey and a lot of money for Christmas?

2. The Kinks - Father Christmas
Because Christmas shouldn’t be just for little rich boys.

3. The Beach Boys - Little Saint Nick
This song’s kinda famous, but I can’t resist the incongruity of a beachy Christmas.

4. Marvin Gaye - Purple Snowflakes
A super-cozy song, with a slightly mournful feel.

5. The Damned - There Ain’t No Sanity Clause
Remember finding out there was no Santa?

6. Run DMC - Christmas in Hollis
Going on the Christmas party mix.

7. Billy Taylor - Bright Star in the East
Would be on the Christmas party mix, if I had the LP.

8. James Brown - Santa Claus Go Straight to the Ghetto
And tell them James Brown sent you!

9. The Raveonettes - The Christmas Song
Have you ever wished you could be snowed in with someone so you didn’t have to go home?

10. The Knife - Reindeer
Because no one ever thinks about the poor reindeer that have to haul around fat-ass Santa and that heavy sleigh.

11. Bjork - Jolasveinar (Icelandic Christmas Carol)
I have no idea what she’s singing about, but something tells me the elves are up to no good.

12. Harvey Danger - Sometimes You Have to Work on Christmas
Christmas isn’t all about joy and presents. Some people actually have to work.

13. The Magnetic Fields - Mister Mistletoe
Oh Mr. Mistletoe/wither and die/you useless weed/for no one have I.

14. Sufjan Stevens - That Was the Worst Christmas Ever!
A pretty song about a shitty Christmas.

15. Tom Waits - Christmas Card from a Hooker in Minneapolis
Gather round with your flasks of bourbon kids, Mr. Waits is gonna tell us a tale.

16. Captain Beefheart & The Magic Band - There Ain’t No Santa Claus on the Evenin’ Stage
If the one above didn’t make you feel tipsy this will.

Also: If like me you have an embarrassing fondness for “Last Christmas” by Wham! you’ll want to bookmark Last-Christmas.com.

Also: If you really just wish Christmas music rocked more check out this punk rock advent calendar (one punk Christmas song download each day in December): Punk-Christmas.com.

Also: I personally can’t stand the Pogues’ “Fairytale of New York” but it’s a pretty standard non-standard holiday tune.

Leave a Comment